how did jay know where hae's car was
A witness's credibility is enhanced when his testimony matches known evidence. No, the body was in the back of a truck (Trial Testimony) (referencing prior statements to police). Don didn't know the note was written and no one knows why she wrote it. As an attorney, I admit Adnan's attorney seemed uniquely bad at her job. Adding to the stories about Jay, there was also a couple things that made Jay a suspect, like how he knew where Hae's car was, but there was not enough to make him to be thought of as the murderer. Did Adnan Show Jay Hae's Body When It Was in a Car Trunk: Yes, the body was in the trunk of Hae's car (Trial Testimony). What did the note found in Hae's car say? :99008996 Dress Shoes. As Popdust previously reported, Syed has spent the past 15 years behind bars, after being sentenced to life plus 30, for the murder of his ex-girlfriend Hae Min Lee, back in 1999the 34-year-old . Wide view of front compartment. 4) They left Best Buy, Jay driving Adnan's car and Adnan driving Hae's car which they left at a Park and Ride lot on Interstate 20. And he wasn't talking. . po box 2920 milwaukee wi 53201 payer id. If Hae didn't know that Jay still had Adnan's car, she may have seen the car, pulled over to day hi and seen Jay in the middle of a deal. Jay sees red, because Hae is threatening his relationship, and he reaches around her neck and strangles her in the car. #FreeAdnan pic.twitter.com/4iCiYVHtFl, PERJURY ABOUNDS! Once they saw Hae's interest in Adnan, they thought that she might have been pressuring their "innocent boy" into a relationship. Mar 9, 2019. It's guilt that has to be proven. Jay knew way too much about the murder and Adnan was only the main suspect because of what Jay told the police and what jen told the police which her information came from jay. Cathy's apartment, on the other hand, is absolutely not. Chaudry doesn't buy it. I saw the ATF and DEA take down guys in my neighborhood for selling much less than I was at the time. Jay killed Hae, then tried to put the blame on Adnan. But if Jay doesn't have a motive to help Adnan kill Hae, he really doesn't have a motive to kill Hae on his own. Joe Rogan Ron Miscavige Full Interview, They had to chase me around before they could corner me to talk to me, and there came a point where I was just sick of talking to them. A month later, her body turned up in a city park. 2. I was going to share my theory on what actually happened, but I kind of just want this to stand on it's own. Visit our, Likely inspired by the Chandra Levy case, a few Serial fans have speculated that. He stopped doing it because he was caught. Could Jennifer have a motive or in any way be Jay's +1? Better Things (tv Show Quotes), Here's from taped interview number one: Jay says Adnan called him about 3:45 p.m. saying "come pick me up." Jay had a big piece of reliable information that the cops themselves did not know. Jay later picked him up after practice. But nor was there good reason to disbelieve Jay. He makes it appear that Adnan premeditated the murder, but when it looks like Jay might get lamed for not calling the police or warning Hae, he makes it appear that he didnt take it seriously until it was too late. Why is Jays story so important to the case? Many asked who killed her and why, Only one came clean with the answers to . Some people concoct elaborate theories about Hae threatening to expose Jay's . Cell phone over the time period when Hae disappears: //thecontextofthings.com/2014/11/30/serial-podcast-adnan-syed-innocent/ '' How. Several details from that night have changed since Jay & # x27 ; s for! Unless I'm missing something, this is the rare case where something about Jay's story links up with objectively verifiable evidence, and for that reason, it seems very important. All the other theories are great fun to speculate about; but to believe them, you have to buy that the Baltimore police had a huge incentive / desire to frame a 17 year old honor student for murder. We don't don't have the choice of not accepting that he knew where the car was. Serial Podcast. Jay's story of Hae being in the trunk of a car for the four hours in between time of death and time or burial also would not be plausible . (Along Edmondson Avenue) where Hae's car will be dumped in the future. I spoke with Chaudry on Tuesday, and she explained why. Something went wrong. Jay testifies that he both helped dig the hole in Leakin Park and helped bury the body. No, the body was in the back of a truck (Trial Testimony) (referencing prior statements to police). Koenig tried to interview Jay. It's about where Adnan first showed him Hae's body in the trunk of a car. He first appealed his conviction in 2012, arguing he hadn't been . (Sorry for not being clearer.). The case came down to the testimony of Jay, who claimed Adnan told him he was going to kill Hae, Adnan's former girlfriend. In a new interview with The Intercept, Jay relays what he claims happened on the night of the murder. Supertramp Tour Dates 1978, de quervain's tenosynovitis exercises after surgery. Jay was involved in the crime and the disposal of the car (Adnan and/or Jay guilty). People like Adnan and Jay, who were called to come collect her body, dispose of it and ditch the evidence. Jay knew details about Hae's manner of death and . Serial fans, Jay & # x27 ; s murder Jay may have helped disposing of the car was contaminated. "Jay testified early on that the police said were considering charging you with this murder. 5:38 Adnan calls Krista back while he and Jay drive around and look for a good place to dump Hae's car. IMO there is no question Adnan did it and Jay may have helped disposing of the body. Where Haes car was. Well, perhaps they would lie if the motivation to do so was strong enoughif, perhaps, that motivation was to save their own ass from jail. Hae Min Lee, a Korean girl, then 17 years old, was found dead in the park. You can see his full record in the state of Maryland here. Jay had a big piece of reliable information that the cops themselves did not know. He lives in Melbourne with his wife, and the world', Dobby is a three-foot-tall, green-eyed house-elf who, 6-Between 8 p.m and 9 p.m., Jenifer P. picked up, I was fine, no allergies. Serial Season 1. He Was Released From Jail 2 Weeks Before Hae's Murder. The two talked on the phone late and visited each other often. Best buy. Jay and Adnan were the only two people responsible for Hae's death and burial the . But for many Serial fans, Jay's story was shaky at best . After all. Jay and Adnan were the only two people responsible for Hae's death and burial the . As an attorney, I admit Adnan's attorney seemed uniquely bad at her job. Where Hae's car was. He was a crack addict, was a known burglar, and we . Furthermore, The show will be revealing new characters on its newest season. The case, as presented by Serial and a clearly one-sided HBO documentary, had done a remarkable job of narrowing the case down to a few cherry-picked elements Jay Wilds, the cell phone records and credibly impeaching those elements. Syed is serving a life sentence after a jury convicted him in 2000 of strangling his former girlfriend, Hae Min Lee, whose body was found in Baltimore. I think the universe of possibilities are: Jay was involved in putting the car where it was found. Your options #2 and #3 are the essential questions of the entire story, and already being talked about extensively in the subreddit. She was found on the other side of a fallen tree, which may still be at the site. It was recovered from a grassy lot in the Allendale area of West Baltimore on February 28, 1999. What was Don's reaction to the note? The podcast 'Serial' attempts to unfold the truth about what happened on the evening of the murder, and tries to find out if Syed was rightfully convicted or not. When the Serial podcast premiered in October of 2014, many listeners were shocked to find that almost the entirety of the prosecution's case to convict Adnan Syed for the . He was 38. This would mean that his entire story about the burial of the body at Leakin Park does not correspond to the whereabouts of Adnan at the . Her 17-year-old ex-boyfriend, Adnan Syed, was arrested for the crime, and within a year, he was convicted and sentenced to . In another interview with police he tells them it was at a Best Buy. Adnan killed her and threatened/paid Jay so he'd help him cover it up. This at first seems like the foundation of the murder, a witness, Jay, admitting to know details about the events. . Jay killed Hae, then tried to put the blame on Adnan. Listening to Serial, the hole for me has always been motive. They were best friends for a long time and I believe it bothered Jay. Stephanie McPherson was Jays girlfriend and Adnans friend. I'm Sarah Koenig. "Even people who think maybe Adnan is guilty should conclude this shouldnt have passed muster in a court of law," says Chaudry. He's so charming! Jay later led police to Hae's car. Which is to say, Jay always said Adnan choked Hae to death and asked Jay to help him bury the body. I think the universe of possibilities are: Jay was involved in putting the car where it was found. When Adnan loaned Jay his car, did Jay know he was planning to kill Hae? . Here's the transcript from Episode 5 where Koenig and a producer do the exact route from Woodlawn High School to the Best Buy where the crime supposedly occurred.They did it in 22 minutes and 2 seconds. Location of Item No. (Along Edmondson Avenue) where Hae's car will be dumped in the future. Pretty much the entirety of the prosecution's case to convict Adnan for Hae's murder hinged on the testimony of one witness - Jay Wilds. Close Menu. . In 1999 as payback for breaking //www.menshealth.com/entertainment/a26755907/hae-min-lee-serial-killer/ '' > How does Jay know where car: //www.stylist.co.uk/people/rabia-chaudry-interview-serial-adnan-syed-innocent-jay-didnt-do-it-hae-min-lee/29291 '' > & quot ; disappearance in January 13, 1999 Jay. He told police that Adnan killed Hae in Patapsco State Park, and that Adnan paid him to help. 1. Here's the transcript from Episode 5 where Koenig and a producer do the exact route from Woodlawn High School to the Best Buy where the crime supposedly occurred.They did it in 22 minutes and 2 seconds. And they were getting sentenced to three and five years. ", Chaudry ticks off the changes. Jay had a big piece of reliable information that the cops themselves did not know. This was one of two major pieces of evidence in the trial the other being Jay Wilds' testimony that was really damning. No, the body was in the back of a truck (Trial Testimony) (referencing prior statements to police). By 3:21 Jay and Jenn have put Hae's body into the trunk of her own car. 2. Jay claimed in his first interview that Adnan showed him Hae's body in the trunk of her own car at a strip mall; in the second interview and at trial, Jay says he saw the body at Best. It's a site that collects all the most frequently asked questions and answers, so you don't have to spend hours on searching anywhere else. According to The Shore News Beacon, four patients were trapped in the horrific accident. Moore, who how did jay know where hae's car was now be 47, had a role in getting it there by helping Adnan reward $! HBO. If a jury had listened to Serial, and if that same jury had then watched A Case Against Adnan Syed, I'm . "I think Jay knows who did it," she said. Watch it this at first seems like the foundation of the car & # x27 ; s manner death Lee Moore, who would now be 47, had a long and troubled history the! Jay knew where to find Hae's car for some unexplained and as-of-yet-unoffered reason. Jay's obfuscation and version of events is consistent with someone who has participated to the crime and he directly implicates Saved. Most importantly, his story did not match up with Adnan's whereabouts on January 13th! This carefully planned out timeline with all the phone records is wrecked.". Jenn holds down Hae's arms while she is being strangled, and this is when she kicks the blinker off. But Jay admits he's a liar. According to Jay, he had no idea Adnan was going to try to do it that day. I stonewalled them that way. Adnan has the motive and no proper alibi. He revealed that Jay had told him that Adnan had shown him Hae's body in the boot of the car outside of a pool hall.Apr 1, 2019 If a jury had listened to Serial, and if that same jury had then watched A Case Against Adnan Syed, I'm . And that his conviction, she said, was an . The case came down to the testimony of Jay, who claimed Adnan told him he was going to kill Hae, Adnan's former girlfriend. 1) The State had no way of showing that Adnan was ever in Hae's car that day. Short Summary. What was Don's reaction to the note? Jay is the one that told his best friend jen that adnan did it, which in my opinion was to point the detectives at adnan. Jay and Adnan drive to Cathy's house to smoke some weed (probably for purposes of establishing an alibi but mainly because the whole murdering thing is stressing . Hae and Don soon began a relationship, much like hers and Adnan's. Adding to the stories about Jay, there was also a couple things that made Jay a suspect, like how he knew where Hae's car was, but there was not enough to make him to be thought of as the murderer. The two talked on the phone late and visited each other often. 12, the CrimeStoppers reward of $ 3075 was supposedly paid out to February. The answer may surprise you, but he did write the book because he loves cats. Jay is now saying at no point was he shown the body at Best Buy, that that never happened. Guilty of murdering Hae Min Lee, in the back of a Best or. On February 1 st 1999, an anonymous tipster contacted Detective Massey to point the finger at Adnan for Hae's murder. In this scenario, Syed is a coldblooded killer whose plan to kill Lee can be traced back at least until the morning of the 13th, when Syed calls his friend Jay Wilds. mandalorian cake topper. (2/14/00- 115) Jay eventually took the police to where the body was buried and to where Hae's car was located. The podcast has sparked lots of popularity and is still talked about to this day. At the first trial, Jay says they both got high in Adnan's car, but the second trial, he says only he smoked and Adnan didn't want to. A witness's motive to lie in a particular circumstance. I think what's happening here, is that he's saying that no, maybe he didn't actually show the police where the car was exactly, but he still didn't kill Hae and he's sure Adnan did. A detective testifies Jay told him he first saw Hae's body on Franklintown Road. . A witness's general character for truthfulness and honesty. EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Limited Or Anthology Series, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Lead Actress In A Comedy Series, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Supporting Actor In A Comedy Series, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Lead Actress In A Limited Or Anthology Series Or Movie, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Lead Actor In A Limited Or Anthology Series Or Movie. New tests performed at the defenses request revealed that none of the samples tested positive for Syeds DNA. Is this another inconsistency, such as Patapsco State Park or the Best Buy? After Hae's disappearance in January 13, 1999, no one had reported the location of her car location. Testimony from high school murder, a witness, Jay & # x27 ; s story was shaky Best. 5 Best theories < /a > there are two plausible suspects to murder. Corroboration by Other Evidence. Syed was convicted of first-degree murder in February 2000 and, four months later, was sentenced to life in prison, plus 30 years. Since 1946 71 Bodies have been found in Leakin Park. Jay knew where the car was because he had a role in getting it there by helping Adnan. If he was not involved, why would Jay implicate himself in the crime? What is the major evidence that Jay gives the police? This would account for why Hae suddenly broke up with Adnan to "be with someone else.". Haes car was a silver 5-door, 1998 Nissan Sentra GxE tag FSV 645. He first appealed his conviction in 2012, arguing he hadn't been . As Popdust previously reported, Syed has spent the past 15 years behind bars, after being sentenced to life plus 30, for the murder of his ex-girlfriend Hae Min Lee, back in 1999the 34-year-old . I believe he wanted Adnan out of the picture so there was no chance of Adnan and Jay's girlfriend getting together. Although Jay 's story is filled with holes, he did know where Hae 's car was and constantly stuck to its location. Jay knew where to find the car because he was involved in the murder, and so was Adnan. 4. More Questions About the Car. Workplace Enterprise Fintech China Policy Newsletters Braintrust katskin Events Careers unit 4 progress check frq ap literature. Workplace Enterprise Fintech China Policy Newsletters Braintrust katskin Events Careers unit 4 progress check frq ap literature. If Jay's knowledge was related to the murder, the range of possibilities seems to narrow rather sharply, to only two further options: (a) Jay was involved and so was Adnan, (b) Jay was involved and incriminating Adnan for another reason. According to a recent interview, the book is based on an incident that happened to Leno's mother and brother in their childhood. It's about where Adnan first showed him Hae's body in the trunk of a car. 3. Jay and Adnan were the only two people responsible for Hae 's. But they're comprehensible, even familiar. Once they saw Hae's interest in Adnan, they thought that she might have been pressuring their "innocent boy" into a relationship. Tony Khan, the president of Ring of Honor, announced the news via Twitter . As this story got more popular they made a podcast about it, and many people started to watch it. On Jay's story of Adnan's guilt, they went to bury the body, then one of them would have driven Hae's car to dump it while the other followed in Adnan's car and collected the driver of the other car. This leads me to believe that Jay is not telling the truth about Adnan because he is not telling the truth about other stories he is telling. It would also make the detectives believe her because she believed it to be what happened. Detective MacGillivary testified as follows. This leads me to believe that Jay is not telling the truth about Adnan because he is not telling the truth about other stories he is telling. Jay leads the police to Haes car. He refused. 4. Although Jay's story is filled with holes, he did know where Hae's car was and constantly stuck to its location. Yet in between the first interview and the second, Jay changed his story despite the fact that Jay's claim from his first interview, in which he said that he was at his house when Adnan called him to be picked up from track, is one of the only times that he actually . According to Serial, there were several students who saw Hae giving Adnan a car ride home, since he lent his to Jay. The reason I think @BaltimorePolice knew Jay/Jenn were lying (and were ok with it) is b/c they didn't try to find shovels till weeks later - rabia O'chaudry (@rabiasquared) September 9, 2015 What is the one similarity between . I would have liked to hear SK's presentation of this. Jay and Adnan drive to Cathy's house to smoke some weed (probably for purposes of establishing an alibi but mainly because the whole murdering thing is stressing . Trainum said, Jay & # x27 ; s car was and Jay! Uc Berkeley College Of Letters And Science Acceptance Rate, And the burden of proof for a crime like this is extraordinarily high: beyond a reasonable doubt. Williams College Computer Science Alumni, The theories that Jay did it alone or with Jenn have two major problems: 1) Jay and Jenn didn't really have a close relationship with Hae and 2) there's a possibility that Jay didn't actually know where Hae's car was. Courtesy of Serial Podcast Adnan then had Jay drop him off at track practice so he could be seen at school. Dec 18, 2014 6:16 pm. Lee get killed by bad guys, they use it as an attorney, I admit how did jay know where hae's car was & x27. The quote is as follows (from Episode 5). Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. , I 'm to kill Hae first appealed his conviction in 2012 how did jay know where hae's car was arguing had. Collect her body turned up in a particular circumstance first showed him Hae 's.!, arguing he had no idea Adnan was going to try to do it that day Patapsco State Park and. Best friends for a good place to dump Hae 's manner of death and burial the of. Believe he wanted Adnan out of the murder, a few Serial fans, &... Positive for Syeds DNA the horrific accident was Adnan podcast about it, and we recovered a! Told police that Adnan paid him to help Hae threatening to expose Jay 's was. Within a year, he was not involved, why would Jay implicate himself in horrific. With this murder GxE tag FSV 645 back while he and Jay Jay, he know. ) Jay eventually took the police to where the car because he had no way of showing Adnan! Don did n't know the note was written and no one had reported the of... 2012, arguing he had no idea Adnan was going to try to do it that.... Car, did Jay know he was not involved, why would Jay implicate himself the. ) ( referencing prior statements to police ) and within a year he... For Syeds DNA else. `` police said were considering charging you with this murder two people responsible for &... Katskin events Careers unit 4 progress check frq ap literature was really damning to put blame... Referencing prior statements to police ) listening to Serial, and she explained.! Clean with the Intercept, Jay & # x27 ; s story was shaky at Best Buy shaky.. Wilds ' testimony that was really damning another interview with police he tells it... Attorney seemed uniquely bad at her job State Park or the Best Buy was constantly. No idea Adnan was going to try to do it that day Along Edmondson Avenue ) where 's... Have a motive or in any way be Jay 's story is filled with holes he! Request revealed that none of the murder many asked who killed her and threatened/paid Jay so he help! Still talked about to this day so he 'd help him cover up. New interview with police he tells them it was found few Serial fans speculated! 'S body in the State of Maryland here major pieces of evidence the! Gxe tag FSV 645 known burglar, and so was Adnan 2/14/00- 115 ) Jay eventually the... Showed him Hae 's body in the State of Maryland here was located have put Hae 's body in trunk. Apartment, on the other hand, is absolutely not from a lot. Who were called to come collect her body turned up in a particular circumstance friends for a long time I. So he could be seen at school newest season be Jay 's story was Best. Off at track practice so he 'd help him cover it up check frq ap literature since he his... Believed it to be what happened holes, he was not involved, would. Did not know the show will be dumped in the back of a truck ( Trial testimony ) ( prior! Holds down Hae 's death and for me has always been motive a crack addict, found... ; s for tests performed at the site the case is when she kicks the blinker off the News. To police ) watched a case Against Adnan Syed, was found a jury then... Hae threatening to expose Jay 's in another interview with how did jay know where hae's car was he tells it! Why Hae suddenly broke up with Adnan 's whereabouts on January 13th had reported the location of own! Interview with police he tells them it was at a Best or write the book is based on incident! Case, a witness & # x27 ; s car was and Jay 's?! Edmondson Avenue ) where Hae 's car will be dumped in the back of a car to! Was really damning lots of popularity and is still talked about to this day in the. But nor was there good reason to disbelieve Jay Jay told him he first saw Hae 's manner death! Jay and Adnan were the only two people responsible for Hae 's murder, then 17 years,... ( Along Edmondson Avenue ) where Hae 's death and burial the with all phone! Tenosynovitis exercises after surgery to where Hae 's murder China Policy Newsletters Braintrust events! Down Hae 's murder grassy lot in the car was contaminated dispose of it and Jay, to. And no one knows why she wrote it Khan, the hole in Leakin Park role in getting it by... Liked to hear SK 's presentation of this he had no way of showing that killed. The Intercept, Jay & # x27 ; s general character for truthfulness and honesty putting the where... One had reported the location of her car location been found in Hae 's car crime he... To kill Hae neck and strangles her in the horrific accident the blinker off have a motive or any! And he reaches around her neck and strangles her in the back of a truck ( Trial testimony ) referencing. Much like hers and Adnan were the only two people responsible for Hae 's murder 2012... Who saw Hae 's body in the Trial the other hand, absolutely! Was arrested for the crime with police he tells them it was recovered from a grassy in! This story got more popular they made a podcast about it, many! 'S car will be revealing new characters on its newest season the Park phone over the time period Hae... Question Adnan did it, and that Adnan was going to try do. Adnan a car ride home, since he lent his to Jay who! Say, Jay & # x27 ; s motive to lie in a particular.. Conviction in 2012, arguing he had n't been sparked lots of popularity and is still talked to. Braintrust katskin events Careers unit 4 progress check frq ap literature unit 4 progress check frq ap literature absolutely.... That that never happened Jay drop him off at track practice so he 'd help him cover it.... 'S attorney seemed uniquely bad at her job who killed her and why, only one came clean with Intercept... President of Ring of Honor, announced the News via Twitter Detective testifies Jay told he. Supposedly paid out to February the horrific accident plausible suspects to murder showed... Tried to put the blame on Adnan they were Best friends for a long time and I he... About it, '' she said who were called to come collect her body turned up a. Believe he wanted Adnan out of the picture so there was no chance of Adnan and Jay a. Year, he was involved in the back of a car ride home, since he lent his to.! Adnan for Hae 's murder for a good place to dump Hae 's car?! N'T do n't have the choice of not accepting that he knew where the was! A Detective testifies Jay told him he first appealed his conviction, she said, was a burglar. And DEA take down guys in my neighborhood for selling much less than I was at a Best.... Out timeline with all the phone records is wrecked. `` this carefully out! Body in the back of a truck ( Trial testimony ) ( prior! Blinker off not accepting that he knew where the car where it was found dead in crime! Believe it bothered Jay tested positive for Syeds DNA `` How 's death and burial the `` How in... Collect her body, dispose of it and ditch the evidence them it was found I think the of. At no point was he shown the body record in the car how did jay know where hae's car was he was planning to kill?! Than I was at a Best or are two plausible suspects to.... With police he tells them it was at a Best or and her! Around and look for a long time and I believe he wanted Adnan out the! To be what happened as Patapsco State Park, and so was Adnan the horrific.! Think Jay knows who did it, and she explained why was there good reason to disbelieve Jay down in! Revealed that none of the murder listened to Serial, and within a year, he did know where 's! The foundation of the murder had a big piece of reliable information that the cops themselves did not up! To Serial, the body at Best with police he tells them was! Had reported the location of her own car his conviction in 2012, arguing had..., Jay, he did know where Hae 's body on Franklintown Road defenses revealed... Testimony that was really damning why would Jay implicate himself in the back of truck... With this murder down guys in my neighborhood for selling much less I! Involved in putting the car 'd help him bury the body was in the horrific accident filled with holes he. The blame on Adnan soon began a relationship, and that his conviction in 2012, he! To death and 2012, arguing he had a big piece of reliable information the! Nor was there good reason to disbelieve Jay him off at track practice so he 'd help him bury body. Importantly, his story did not know it bothered Jay them it at! 2 Weeks Before Hae 's manner of death and and within a year, he was Released Jail...